Circular vs Square Filters: Which One Is The Best?

/ Accessories / By

When it comes to professional photography, filters play a key role in controlling light, reducing glare, and enhancing the final image. But the question remains, should you invest in circular vs square filters? Both have their pros and cons, but deciding which is best for your style depends on various factors. After experimenting with both types over the years, I have come to realise that each shines in specific situations. Let’s break it down to help you make an informed decision.

What Are Circular and Square Filters in Photography?

Filters come in two primary types: circular and square. Circular filters screw directly onto the front of your camera lens. They are convenient, portable, and easy to use. Many photographers, myself included, start with them. Square filters, on the other hand, are part of a holder system. This system lets you slide filters in and out, offering more flexibility. However, they can be bulkier and less intuitive for quick, on-the-go shooting.

Why Filters Are Essential for Professional Photography

Regardless of their shape, filters are crucial for professional photography. They help control the amount of light entering the lens, reduce reflections, and can even enhance colours. Whether you are a landscape photographer dealing with harsh lighting or a portrait photographer needing subtle enhancements, the right filter can make all the difference.

Advantages of Circular Filters for Professional Photography

Circular filters are often marketed as the go-to option for photographers due to their simplicity and convenience. And to some extent, that’s true. Over time, I’ve appreciated the fact that they are lightweight and quick to attach, especially when I’m out in the field.

Key Benefits:

  • Easy to use: Simply screw it onto your lens and you’re ready to go. There’s no need to carry additional holders or parts.
  • Portability: Circular filters are compact and easy to throw in your camera bag without taking up much space.
  • Ideal for casual photography: If you’re shooting portraits or street photography, where speed matters, circular filters are a no-brainer.

However, circular filters have their limitations, especially in more demanding situations like landscape photography, where precision is essential. One thing that always frustrated me is their limited versatility, you are locked into one size per lens thread.

Advantages of Square Filters for Professional Photographers

Square filters may seem like overkill at first, trust me, I was hesitant to switch. But after using them for landscape shots, I quickly realised that they offer a level of flexibility that circular filters just can’t match.

Where They Shine:

  • Flexibility with different lenses: Square filters, used with a holder, can be adapted to multiple lenses with varying thread sizes. You only need one filter set instead of buying multiple circular filters for different lenses.
  • Precision control: For wide angle photography, square filters allow you to control light across the entire frame more evenly. This is particularly useful for graduated neutral density (ND) filters, where you need to balance exposure between the sky and the foreground.
  • Stacking filters: Square filter systems make it easier to stack filters without worrying about vignetting, a common issue I faced with circular filters.

But here is where I struggled: the added bulk of square filters. It’s not just the filters themselves. The holder system takes up a lot of space in your camera bag. Setting them up also takes more time. This makes them less ideal for fast paced shoots or travel photography.

Circular vs Square Filters for Landscape Photography

For landscape photography, balancing exposure between the sky and land is crucial. Square filters are better for this. I have found square graduated ND filters provide more precision. You can slide the filter up or down to adjust light levels where needed. This is nearly impossible with circular filters.

On the other hand, when I am hiking or moving quickly, circular filters are more convenient. Setting up a square filter system can be a hassle. In those moments, a circular polarizer works well to reduce reflections and enhance colors.

Circular vs SQUARE Filters for Wide Angle Photography

For wide angle photography, square filters usually outperform circular ones. With wide lenses, stacking circular filters often causes vignetting. Square filters prevent this since the holder system is designed to avoid dark edges.

That said, for less demanding wide angle shots where filter stacking isn’t needed, circular filters still hold their ground and are easier to use.

Best Filters for Professional Photography: Circular vs Square

So, which is better for professional photography? There is no clear answer. It depends on your style and needs. For portraits or casual shoots, circular filters are the easiest and most efficient. For landscape work or wide angle lenses, square filters offer more control and flexibility for professional results.

Personally, I now keep both types in my gear bag, choosing based on the demands of the shoot. When convenience matters, I reach for circular filters. But when precision and versatility are key, I go for my square filters every time.

How to Choose Between Circular vs Square Filters

If you’re on the fence about which to choose, here’s a quick guide:

  • Go for circular filters if you need something portable, quick, and convenient. They are great for everyday photography and when you need a fast setup.
  • Opt for square filters if you shoot landscapes or wide angle scenes where you need precision and the ability to stack multiple filters without vignetting.

Conclusion: Which Filter Is Right for You?

After years of using both circular and square filters, my advice is to choose based on the type of photography you do most often. If you want something simple and lightweight, circular filters will serve you well. But if you are a landscape photographer or work with wide angle lenses, the precision and flexibility of square filters are hard to beat.

At the end of the day, neither is definitively “better”, it all depends on your style and the demands of your shoots. Personally, I have found value in having both types at my disposal, and you might, too.

When choosing between circular and square filters, it is essential to consider the type of photography you specialise in. Both options offer unique benefits depending on your needs. For quick, on the go shots, circular filters provide simplicity and speed. However, for more precise control, especially in landscape photography, square filters tend to offer better flexibility and results. If you are new to filters and want to understand how to get started, check out our Beginner’s Guide to Using Photography Circular Filters for a deeper dive into how circular filters work and when they’re most effective.

For those looking to invest in high quality filters, it is important to choose trusted brands that offer durability and precision. One such option is Schneider-Kreuznach’s B+W Filters, known for their exceptional performance and reliability. Whether you are searching for polarisers, UV filters, or neutral density filters, B+W provides a range of filter types designed to enhance your photography results. Explore their selection to find the right fit for your camera setup.

FAQ